Thursday, March 12, 2009

A Little Bit of Political Explanation

i normally avoid politics on this blog; however, I did follow with interest the elections held recently in Israel. Frankly, I was more than a little confused as to who won, who lost and who all the parties were. I assume/hope that Israelis can figure things out. But in case you can't, the following was sent to me via email (don't know who to credit for the original).


Teacher: Good morning. Your parents. . . invited me today. . . to give you a private lesson in Israeli citizenship.
Pupil: Yeah, we made Aliyah from San Francisco last month, and I 'm missing a lot of material in the Ezrakhoot (citizenship) course, though I did try to follow the news before we came.
Teacher: Not to worry. Today we'll talk about, "How the Israeli electoral system works."
Pupil: That's great. I'm really confused by what I read in the papers and blogs.
Teacher: Let's start with the results of last week's . . . elections.
Pupil: OK. Who got the most votes?
Teacher: Tsipi Livni, head of the Kadima (Forward) party, with 28 seats.
Pupil: So Ms. Livni won, right?
Teacher: No, she lost. It doesn't look like she'll be able to get enough partners to form a majority government.
Pupil: What about Bibi Netanyahu?
Teacher: He got 27 seats. As the leader of the right, he may form a coalition of 65 right wing party seats.
Pupil: Then he won, I guess.
Teacher: No, Avigdor Lieberman (Israel is Our Home) won.
Pupil: How many seats did he get?
Teacher: 15.
Pupil: So how did he win?
Teacher: That's the way politics in Israel works.
Pupil: It's confusing with three major parties!
Teacher: What, three? Who told you three? There's also the Labour party. They once were the largest party in Israel, and ruled for the first 30 years. Today they have 11 seats.
Pupil: Four parties? How do you ever get anyth---
Teacher: Stop interrupting me! Four? Who told you four? There's also Shas:
Pupil: What's Shas?
Teacher: Ultra-Orthodox Moroccans. They appeared on the scene some twenty years ago and they have around 12 seats today.
Pupil: How bewildering. What are the main issues that divide the parties?
Teacher: The crucial issue is the 'territories' that Israel gained during the war in 1967. If you believe that these areas are an integral part of Israel and that Jews should continue to live there, you are on the 'right.' If you believe that Israel should withdraw from these territories, or make some kind of compromise, then you are on the 'left.'
Pupil: I read that Bibi supported the retreat from Gaza and the expulsion of 10,000 Jews .. His party must be really far left. Right?
Teacher: Right. I mean, no, he 's on the right. His Likud party has always been right.
Pupil: What about Lieberman?
Teacher: He says that there's too much power in the hands of rabbis. He wants secular marriage and religious freedom.
Pupil: So he's the extreme left. Right?
Teacher: Wrong! Wrong! Wrong again! He's way right. Extreme left is "Meretz". Their slogan is "We won't compromise."
Pupil: That makes them radical right, right?
Teacher: You have snow for brains, I see. Wrong; LEFT! They refuse all compromise , unless, of course, it is with Arabs. Some of them actually believe that the Jewish state should not exist.
Pupil: I'm getting dizzy. So, all 120 Knesset seats will be taken by these six parties. That's really a lot.
Teacher: You're kidding me, right? What, six? Who told you six? You've forgotten National Religious parties: The Jewish Home party, for Jewish settlement of Judah and Samaria, and the National Union, who are really really absolutely for Jewish settlement of Judah and Samaria. Then there are also ultra orthodox Ashkenazim. Some of them actually believe that the Jewish state should not exist.
Pupil: Like Meretz, correct?
Teacher: Corr- what, are you crazy? Stop blathering and let me finish: There are also three parties exclusively for Arabs.
Pupil: Let me guess: Some of the Arabs actually believe that the Jewish state should not exist.
Teacher: Now you're catching on.
Pupil: I can't catch on to anything.. I've had it! This is too much for me! No country has twelve separate parties!
Teacher: What twelve? Who told you twelve? Where are you going? We've just started. There's the Male Rights party, so all those divorced men whose wives got custody can take their kids out of the house. There's the Pensioner's party, to help the elderly get more often out of the house. There's the Handicapped party, who want to get out of the house and have a place to go, and there's For the Kids' Sake party, which is trying to put kids taken out of their non functional households back into the house. Of course you can't overlook "Hadash."
Pupil: (glazed eyes): That means 'new.'
Teacher: Very good. They want a new system: Communism.
Then we have 'The Strong Israel party. They promise to fight organized crime. Unfortunately, Kadima is organized crime. There's also Tsomet--
Pupil: STOP! STOP!
Teacher: Very good. Stop for the Tsomet party. The name means 'intersection.'
Pupil: NO! STOP STOP!! I can't take any more.
Teacher: You must listen! What about Leader party?' -- to curb the monopoly of the banks?
The Light party? The Responsibility party? The 'Noodleman Renewal Russian party?'
Pupil: (writhing on floor): No, this cannot be real. Make him stop!
Teacher: The Green party to save the environment.
Pupil: ( weaker) Nooooooooooooooooo..
Teacher: The Leftist Religious Green party, who are in favor of territorial compromise as long as we first separate the territory into glass, plastic and organic.
Pupil: Noooooooooooooooooooooooooooo!
Teacher: The Green Leaf party fighting to legalize cannabis.
Pupil: Nooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo!
Teacher: And most important, The Green Leaf Senior/ Holocaust Survivor Merger party, who will fight for the right to smoke their old cannabis and get more reparations at the same time.
Pupil: ( is now lying motionless on the floor).
Teacher: What's the matter with him.. We've only gone through the first 28!
Twenty-eight? Who told you twenty-eight! Hey, get up! There's a lot more to do!
(sighs). . ..What do you expect an American kid to know about democracy?
Note: The above is based on a true political system. In the Israeli elections held on Feb 10, there were THIRTY-SEVEN separate lists! While the above sketch is not comprehensive, not one party mentioned above is made up --- no matter how far-fetched they seem.

5 comments:

nmf #7 said...

Heh. This is exactly how I feel when trying to figure these things out!! Thanks for the perfect description.
So who won again?

SuperRaizy said...

Oh, my head hurts. Incredibly enough, that really IS a true depiction. I think that the Israelis have taken the concept of democracy a bit too far.

Anonymous said...

Hard enough here in the US to figure out who to vote for with only 2 or 3 candidates. Can't even imagine how the Israelis figure out who to vote for. Although it doesn't seem to matter who they vote for because the winner can be the loser maybe. Does anyone over there really understand the process?

Anonymous said...

This would be very funny if it were not, sadly, so very true.

Bas~Melech said...

What Ruth said. Except it actually IS kind of funny...